View profile

😞 Holy Dissatisfaction

Good morning, Friends. Today, I look at the experience of disappointment and dissatisfaction. I, for
😞 Holy Dissatisfaction
By C. Wess Daniels • Issue #19 • View online
Good morning, Friends.
Today, I look at the experience of disappointment and dissatisfaction. I, for one, feel like I have been surrounded by immense disappointment and so this is as much for me, as it is something I want to share with you.
As I was exploring this topic this week, I was reminded of my good friend and someone I hold in the highest esteem, Stan Thornburg. He understood and spoke about what he called “Holy Dissatisfaction.” Stan was a Quaker pastor from the Pacific Northwest who was known as an Angelic Troublemaker among many there.
When we first moved to the PNW in 2009, I kept hearing his name and was told to meet him as soon as I could. Stan and I became fast friends, I loved his perspective, his courage to go against the grain, his commitment to the God who liberates, and his really wry sense of humor. I remember meeting him in portland at a little pie shop he loved on Alberta street regularly to talk shop and to toss around ideas. The last couple years of his life - he died in 2014 - attended and became a member of the Quaker meeting I pastored. And it was during his funeral that I made a number of friends who ultimately set my life on a different trajectory, but that is for another day.
A month before he died, he preached in the meeting on the topic of holy dissatisfaction, a sermon I have listened to over the years many times. And as I listen to it again, I see the ways in which both his witness, along with these words, have stuck with me and emboldened me in my ministry. Stan was someone who practiced holy dissatisfaction, especially when it came to people who identify as LGBTQ and the church. The disdain expressed by the church for those in the LGBTQ community broke Stan’s heart and drove him to do something about this holy dissatisfaction he experienced. As I think about dealing with my own disappointment and dissatisfaction with the way things are going at work and in the world, I reminded of Stan’s life as a witness to all of this.
I ask of you:
When have you experienced holy dissatisfaction?

Thank you for reading. If you found this helpful please share it with others.
Hold fast in thy way,
C. Wess Daniels
Greensboro, NC (Haw River Watershed)

Reflection: Holy Disappointment
Here are a few reflections on the theme of disappointment and dissatisfaction:
How do you deal with disappointment? What does it feel like in your body?
Recently, as I have experienced the continued cuts to faculty and staff and dramatic changes at the college where I work, I have felt a deep sense of disappointment and dissatisfaction, knowing that these people don’t deserve this, the students don’t deserve it, and this college doesn’t deserve this. Add to this the sense of feeling powerlessness to change the situation or do something different and it becomes very overwhelming. I have noticed recently that the physical feeling that goes along with this experience has been for me headaches, a tight chest, and even a punch to the gut. I’m not telling you this to gain sympathy, but to help identify how the “emotion” feels physically. I have noticed that my body often knows what I am experiencing before my head knows (or admits). I’ll notice my chest is tight and then begin wondering what is going on? The first step is to recognize where this disappointment is rising up and name it as such.
Thus, can you identify times when you have experienced deep disappointment and what it feels like in your body?
•◎•
What do we do with this disappointment once we notice it is there? David Whyte, the Irish poet, in his book, Consolations, says this about disappointment:
What we call disappointment may be just the first stage in our emancipation into the next greater pattern of existence. To be disappointed is to reappraise not only reality itself but our foundational relationship to the pattern of events places and people that surround us, and which, until we were properly disappointed, we had misinterpreted and misunderstood; disappointment is the first, fruitful foundation of genuine heartbreak from which we risk ourselves in a marriage, in a work, in a friendship, or with life itself.
The measure of our courage is the measure of our wiliness to embrace disappointment, to turn towards it rather than away, the understanding that every real conversation of life involves having our hearts broken somewhere along the way and that there is no sincere path we can follow where we will not be fully and immeasurably let down and brought to earth, and where what initially looks like a betrayal, eventually puts real ground under our feet.
I find it hard to admit to feeling disappointed for many reasons, but often it is rooted in this sense of “I misunderstood or misinterpreted the patterns and events.”
When I first read this section from Whyte, I thought what I was hearing in this was to give into disappointment, to just deal with it. But as I keep coming back to it, I see and hear something different. This last line about what “initially looks like a betrayal, eventually puts real ground under our feet” seems to be saying that we need to face disappointment head on. When we begin to deal within the reality of things as they are that gives us ground upon which we can move and respond. Wishful thinking and denial are bottomless floors upon which no lasting change has ever been created or sustained. It is okay to misunderstand and misinterpret but once we are aware of the “foundational relationship to the pattern of events places and people that surround us” we e can move forward.
Can I identify disappointment in my life? What would result from my embracing that disappointment? And what happens when I push it away? What is the courageous act for me in this moment?
•◎•
Lastly, we get back to Stan Thornburg’s message on “Holy Dissatisfaction.”
Stan describes what he calls “holy dissatisfaction” as:
“Holy Dissatisfaction comes from a vision that you have rooted in God’s best for humanity,” and the dissonance and broken heart that comes from the church, an institution, or our society acting out of sync with that vision.
Stan and David Whyte both connect a broken heart to this kind of disappointment. Stan’s broken-heartedness comes from a vision that God desires something so much better for us that “..starts deep in your heart and moves to your soul and then it becomes part of you.” When you have this kind of vision you are lifted up by God’s presence and compelled to not back down. God asks you to say what you have been given with confidence and to stand firm in the conviction that “this is not the way things should be.” And of course, when people are faithful to this, as Stan knew well, “That’s when people get in trouble.”
In the message, Stan outlines various examples of people who shared in this holy dissatisfaction from Jesus, to early Quakers, to abolitionists, Rev. Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. to even those in the Northwest Yearly Meeting who pushed against the anti-LGBTQ theology of their community.
Today, those protesting against anti-poor economics in the Poor People’s Campaign, those pushing for police reform and less (or no?!) violence in our communities, those who refuse to allow racism and white supremacy to be acceptable forms of control in our country, those pushing our institutions - educational and otherwise - to live up to their real potential and to honor the community they are entrusted with, are all - I believe - motivated by a vision rooted in an understanding that God calls us to something so much better, something far more just, peaceful, and loving. We can get there if we allow that dissatisfaction rooted in God’s vision and the accompanying broken-heartedness to push us forward.
❓Query for Personal Reflection
  • How do you connect to this experience of holy dissatisfaction?
  • When have you felt this deep in your bones and how have you responded?
  • What examples do you see around you where this dissatisfaction unfolding?
🐦 Tweet Thread of the Week
🔗 Dress Down Friday Links
Drinking Alone | Commonweal Magazine
📆 Upcoming Events
This Sunday at 6pm EST
This Sunday at 6pm EST
QUAKER THEOLOGICAL DISCUSSION GROUP | DECEMBER 11–12, 2020
QUAKER THEOLOGICAL DISCUSSION GROUP | DECEMBER 11–12, 2020
💚🧠 Final Thought
“I would encourage you to seek this sense of holy dissatisfaction, this vision for God’s next step, and consider its cost against your resources, and then trust God will move you forward.” - Stan Thornburg (Camas Friends Church April, 2014)
☕️ Thank you for Supporting This Newsletter
You support this newsletter by reading it, sharing it with your friends, and/or by contributing financially to the making of this newsletter, and my other ministries.
Thank you! -Wess 💚☕️
Did you enjoy this issue?
C. Wess Daniels

👉🏼 Old and New (Spiritual) Technologies For Life Today

In this weekly newsletter you'll find:

🔄 Old and new (spiritual) technologies for life in the faith of empire
💥 Wisdom for living well from the Quaker tradition
🌱 Renewal and change work in order to mobilize communities for love & liberation.
🧰 Resources, events, articles & more

🔆 Visit my website: https://gatheringinlight.com

👀 Read current issues below
👋🏼 Thanks for subscribing - C. Wess Daniels, Ph.D. (he/him).

If you don't want these updates anymore, please unsubscribe here.
If you were forwarded this newsletter and you like it, you can subscribe here.
Powered by Revue
1602 West End Place Greensboro, NC 27403